Close menu




June 24th, 2020 | 06:57 CEST

NEL, Nikola, Tesla - is Germany facing a new billion euro scandal?

  • Electromobility
Photo credits: pixabay.com

The Kiel Institute for the World Economy (IfW) is a renowned organization focusing on research, economic policy advice and analysis. It sees itself as the research institute for globalisation issues in Germany. The institute cooperates worldwide with universities, research institutions and think tanks. In short: the independent organisation is credible and its statement carries weight. One of the latest studies on the subject of e-cars has now brought clarity to light, as we have already reported, which cannot be in the interest of German politics and how the exposure of a scandal appears. Outsiders are asking the question; how can it be that tax money and subsidies are flowing to increase greenhouse gas emissions by 73%? One thing at a time.

time to read: 4 minutes | Author: Mario Hose
ISIN: CA26780A1084 , NO0010081235 , US6541101050 , US88160R1014

Table of contents:


    Green power is on the rise

    In 2019, 54% of the electricity mix in Germany consisted of conventional energy sources such as lignite (19.8%), nuclear energy (13.8%), natural gas (10.5%) and hard coal (9.5%). The so-called renewable energies accounted for 46%. A large part came from wind energy (24.5%), photovoltaics (9.1%), biomass (8.6%) and hydropower (3.8%). In total, net electricity of 513 TWh (= billion kWh) was generated. The share of green electricity increased by 13.3% compared to 2018. But who will compensate for the loss of nuclear power? Hopefully we will see.

    Where will the extra electricity come from?

    Given that e-cars generate additional demand for electricity, it must be generated from scalable coal-fired power generation, which increases CO2 emissions. "Electric cars today drive de facto with 100% coal-based electricity," says IfW researcher Prof. Dr. Dr. Ulrich Schmidt. "This is because the share of renewable energy in their electricity consumption is not available to displace fossil fuels elsewhere, and the increased electricity demand requires the additional use of fossil fuels." Plainly and conclusively to the point.

    The big miscalculation

    In the current Kiel Policy Brief "Elektromobilität und Klimaschutz: Die große Fehlkalkulation", researcher Schmidt has reviewed and published the climate balance of electromobility, taking into account the rising demand for electricity and the electricity mix, which now disenchants the political ideology that e-cars are automatically green with hard facts. "First when the energy transition is well advanced and the electricity is almost exclusively generated from renewable energies, the electric car will be more climate-friendly than modern diesel vehicles."

    What does using an e-car mean today?

    An e-car increases the emission of greenhouse gases by 73% compared to a modern diesel car. The EU Commission estimates that even in 2050 the share of fossil fuels will still be around 40%, so an end is not even in sight. This means that even then, electric cars would still be running de facto on 100% carbon electricity and cause emissions of around 300 grams of CO2 per kilometer, whereas modern diesel vehicles only emit around 173 grams of CO2 according to an ADAC study, the IfW study states.

    Have studies been embellished for the Corona stimulus package?

    The researcher's reference to two more recent studies is particularly controversial. These studies did not take into account the significant increase in electricity consumption and thus led to an embellished picture of electromobility, which was given special consideration in the Corona economic stimulus package by means of an additional purchase premium. An erroneous presentation with serious consequences for citizens due to additional environmental and tax burdens. "Even if the car is refuelled with 'its own' solar power, as one of the studies recommends, it would be more climate-friendly to feed this into the power grid and thus reduce the proportion of coal-based electricity," explains Schmidt.

    In addition to the IfW, there are also other sources of information that question the environmental protection of electric mobility. The white paper "The road to low CO2 mobility" from Stahl Automotive Consulting GmbH & Co. KG offers further insights into details.

    Does diesel have no alternative?

    According to the Federal Motor Transport Authority, a total of 630.84 billion kilometres were covered by passenger cars alone in 2018. Assuming an average consumption of an electric car of 15 kWh per 100 kilometres, this would result in an electricity consumption of 18.4% of the net electricity generation in Germany if the switch to electric mobility were complete, according to Schmidt's analysis. Where additional and environmentally friendly electricity can come from remains unclear.

    What consequences the results of this study will have for NEL ASA, Nikola and Tesla worldwide is still open. The critical point is the additional use of coal for the production of hydrogen and charging of batteries. In 2019, there were around 2,425 coal-fired power plants on the grid worldwide (source: https://www.visualcapitalist.com/every-coal-power-plant-1927-2019/). Anyone who wants to be mobile in Germany will have to drive modern diesel cars for the time being in the interests of environmental protection. Politicians, meanwhile, have to put up with the accusation that they are misleading. People who have bought an e-car to protect the environment are thus doing themselves a disservice.

    Solution for greener diesel with hydrogen

    Innovative solutions can nevertheless contribute to environmental protection now and today. The Canadian company dynaCERT has developed a hydrogen technology that generates the energy carrier itself on board and feeds it into the engine via the air supply as a catalyst during the combustion of diesel. Increasing efficiency reduces fuel consumption and emissions of pollutants. The gap in CO2 emissions between diesel passenger cars and electric cars can therefore be even wider. It remains exciting.

    Nothing is as it seems

    In conclusion, the topic of electromobility is extremely complex and there are different interests, opinions and interpretations of data. The ostracism of the diesel engine is just as wrong as the glorification of the electric car. If the consumer groups are now insecure, then no one should be surprised. At the moment it seems that electric mobility is part of a political ideology and only works with taxpayers' money at the expense of the solidarity community, without fulfilling the actual promise to protect the environment.

    Links to further information:
    ifw-kiel.de
    sac-group.eu/mobility-germany
    dynacert.com
    nelhydrogen.com
    nikolamotor.com
    tesla.com


    Conflict of interest

    Pursuant to §85 of the German Securities Trading Act (WpHG), we point out that Apaton Finance GmbH as well as partners, authors or employees of Apaton Finance GmbH (hereinafter referred to as "Relevant Persons") may in the future hold shares or other financial instruments of the mentioned companies or will bet on rising or falling on rising or falling prices and therefore a conflict of interest may arise in the future. conflict of interest may arise in the future. The Relevant Persons reserve the shares or other financial instruments of the company at any time (hereinafter referred to as the company at any time (hereinafter referred to as a "Transaction"). "Transaction"). Transactions may under certain circumstances influence the respective price of the shares or other financial instruments of the of the Company.

    Furthermore, Apaton Finance GmbH reserves the right to enter into future relationships with the company or with third parties in relation to reports on the company. with regard to reports on the company, which are published within the scope of the Apaton Finance GmbH as well as in the social media, on partner sites or in e-mails, on partner sites or in e-mails. The above references to existing conflicts of interest apply apply to all types and forms of publication used by Apaton Finance GmbH uses for publications on companies.

    Risk notice

    Apaton Finance GmbH offers editors, agencies and companies the opportunity to publish commentaries, interviews, summaries, news and etc. on news.financial. These contents serve information for readers and does not constitute a call to action or recommendations, neither explicitly nor implicitly. implicitly, they are to be understood as an assurance of possible price be understood. The contents do not replace individual professional investment advice and do not constitute an offer to sell the share(s) offer to sell the share(s) or other financial instrument(s) in question, nor is it an nor an invitation to buy or sell such.

    The content is expressly not a financial analysis, but rather financial analysis, but rather journalistic or advertising texts. Readers or users who make investment decisions or carry out transactions on the basis decisions or transactions on the basis of the information provided here act completely at their own risk. There is no contractual relationship between between Apaton Finance GmbH and its readers or the users of its offers. users of its offers, as our information only refers to the company and not to the company, but not to the investment decision of the reader or user. or user.

    The acquisition of financial instruments entails high risks that can lead to the total loss of the capital invested. The information published by Apaton Finance GmbH and its authors are based on careful research on careful research, nevertheless no liability for financial losses financial losses or a content guarantee for topicality, correctness, adequacy and completeness of the contents offered here. contents offered here. Please also note our Terms of use.


    Der Autor

    Mario Hose

    Born and raised in Hannover, Lower Saxony follows social and economic developments around the globe. As a passionate entrepreneur and columnist he explains and compares the most diverse business models as well as markets for interested stock traders.

    About the author



    Related comments:

    Commented by Nico Popp on January 12th, 2022 | 10:36 CET

    BYD, Altech Advanced Materials, Volkswagen: Who is as innovative as Tesla?

    • Electromobility

    For years, e-cars lagged behind conventional drives in many areas: The ranges were significantly lower, and comfort remained inferior to classic combustion engines. In the meantime, however, things have changed. Chinese manufacturers, in particular, are scoring points with ranges of 1,000 km. Modern e-cars have also long been packed with gadgets that make the hearts of tech-savvy car enthusiasts beat faster. Does this mean that the development of e-cars is at an end? Not at all! We present three companies from the industry and analyze their innovative strength.

    Read

    Commented by André Will-Laudien on January 6th, 2022 | 13:39 CET

    Nvidia, BrainChip, Daimler, Infineon - Not only Tesla can build e-cars!

    • Electromobility

    Intelligent and powerful chips remain in demand like road salt in the depths of winter. The supply chains are still struggling, and the scarce raw materials are increasing the cost prices. As a result, prices for high-tech materials will continue to skyrocket in the new year. The car manufacturers will probably be hit hardest, as it will not be possible to raise prices at will, especially in Europe, because of foreign competition. Innovation could be an effective means of combating the erosion of margins. We present a few innovative ideas for investors.

    Read

    Commented by Armin Schulz on December 30th, 2021 | 11:35 CET

    Standard Lithium, Manganese X Energy, Daimler Truck - The future of the battery

    • Electromobility

    Electric cars would never have existed with the conventional lead-acid batteries popularly used in remote controls and the like. The development only became possible with the invention of lithium-ion batteries, which can be charged much more often and thus significantly increase battery life. The advantage of electric mobility is emission-free driving. The disadvantage is longer refueling times, shorter range and the need for lithium and other rare raw materials, such as manganese. It is precisely the batteries that make electromobility so expensive. It is not for nothing that Tesla is trying to push the price down to under USD 100 per kilowatt-hour. Experts expect that the prices of internal combustion and e-cars will then converge.

    Read